Is cereal soup?
Dev
Soup is solid food in a liquid, eaten with a spoon, from a bowl. Cereal is the same math. You cannot escape this.
Cole
Soup is cooked. Soup has a stock. Nobody simmers Cheerios. Cereal is cereal.
The ruling
Ruling: Cereal is not soup. Milk is a delivery system, not a stock. By the 'things in a bowl' test, ice water is soup — the court has to stop somewhere.