Settle an argument with AI by bringing both people into one chat with the same Judge. Each person makes their case, the Judge asks for the other side before ruling, and everyone sees the verdict in the shared thread.
Start a room and invite the other person by link or text. Each of you explains what happened in your own words.
If only one person has spoken, the Judge asks for the other side. No verdict until both people have had their say.
Once both sides have spoken, tap Get the Verdict. The Judge explains its decision and gives a Sentence, a small consequence or rule for next time.
The Judge can side with one person, split the ruling, or call it close. It explains its reasoning in the shared chat.
Dishes, thermostat disputes, who owes dinner, movie trivia, group bets, and the argument about pineapple on pizza. Bring in the people involved and let the Judge hear their cases. For serious legal, medical, or safety questions, use qualified help instead.
The Judge is instructed not to rule on custody disputes, legal matters, or safety concerns, and to direct those questions to appropriate help. It waits for both sides and can give a split ruling when the evidence doesn't favor either person.
See how the Judge rules on familiar debates, then bring your own argument into a room. Your verdict depends on what everyone says.
Maya wins on paper. Theo wins at the table.
Over. With one exception Jonah gets to keep.
Neither. 70 by day, 67 overnight.
Cole. Cereal is not soup.
Nina. Pineapple is allowed. On her half.
Both are correct. Jo wins the room, Max wins the footnote.
Ava, on the method. Ben, on the timing.
Depends on the flight, and the court assigns it.
Eli wins dessert. Rosa wins birthdays.
Both. The answer is 'whichever one fits your actual life.'
There isn't one explanation for every recurring argument. You can both describe what's happening, and the AI can ask questions about where you disagree. For more, read How to stop having the same argument.
Hearing both sides gives the Judge more context, but AI can still make mistakes. Settle It requires both people to participate before a verdict is available. Everyone sees the decision and can challenge the reasoning.
They tap your link and can read immediately. To reply, they create a free account in about ten seconds. iPhone, Android and web all work.
Argue with it. You can ask follow-up questions or challenge its reasoning. The Judge can reconsider when new information changes the case.
Yes. Free includes all seven rooms, 10 AI replies and 3 Judge verdicts per day, and 1 AI image per month. Plus ($9.99/month) includes unlimited AI replies and 20 AI images per month.
ChatGPT began retiring group chats on July 9, 2026. Poe supports group chats with up to 200 people. SharedChat's Judge has instructions for disputes, including waiting for both sides before ruling. You don't have to write those instructions yourself. See the full comparison.